Current:Home > StocksDefamation case against Nebraska Republican Party should be heard by a jury, state’s high court says -Lighthouse Finance Hub
Defamation case against Nebraska Republican Party should be heard by a jury, state’s high court says
View
Date:2025-04-18 04:59:07
OMAHA, Neb. (AP) — The Nebraska Supreme Court ruled Friday that a jury should decide whether former Republican state legislative candidate Janet Palmtag was defamed by her own political party in a 2020 race that highlighted a growing schism within the state GOP.
The high court’s decision reversed a lower court ruling in which a judge sided with the Nebraska Republican Party by tossing out the lawsuit before a jury could hear it.
The lawsuit centers on campaign mailers sent out by the party in October 2020 that falsely claimed Palmtag — a lifelong Nebraska Republican — had been charged with mishandling business trust accounts and had lost her real estate license. The mailers, sent to about 3,200 households of registered voters, included statements that Palmtag “broke the law and lost her real estate license,” and that her license had been “revoked.” The mailers also described Palmtag as “too irresponsible to keep her license.”
The mailers grossly mischaracterized a 2018 disciplinary case out of Iowa that found Palmtag’s real estate brokerage firm responsible for improperly transferring funds from an Iowa account to a Nebraska one. It was not Palmtag but another real estate agent who worked for the firm that had made the improper transaction. The company paid a $500 fine for the oversight.
Two years later, Palmtag canceled her Iowa real estate license, citing a lack of business for her firm there. The decision was not related to the disciplinary case, she said.
Palmtag demanded corrections to the mailers, but the state party refused. Following her loss in the November 2020 election, she sued the state GOP for defamation.
In 2022, a judge threw out the lawsuit, saying that while the state party’s mailers were defamatory, Palmtag would not be able to prove to a jury that the party acted with actual malice.
The state’s high court disagreed in its reversal, noting that Palmtag had shown that the GOP failed to investigate whether Palmtag was the subject of the Iowa real estate disciplinary case or whether that had been the catalyst for her inactivating her Iowa real estate license. Palmtag also presented as evidence text messages between then-state GOP Executive Director Ryan Hamilton and a GOP vendor, who responded upon being told of the party’s accusations against Palmtag, “OK that’s not real.”
“A jury could find the party chose not to investigate further in a purposeful avoidance of the truth,” Justice John Freudenberg wrote for the court.
Palmtag is “eager for a jury to hear the case,” her attorney, David Domina of Omaha said Friday.
The party’s mailers and other campaign efforts were intended to help state Sen. Julie Slama of Peru, Palmtag’s rival in the officially nonpartisan race.
Slama was appointed in 2019 to the seat by then-Gov. Pete Ricketts to fill a vacancy. When she ran for the seat in 2020, Ricketts backed her, but his predecessor, fellow Republican Dave Heineman, endorsed Palmtag. That exposed a split in the party, with some lined up to support Palmtag and Heineman — the longest-serving governor in Nebraska — while others backed Slama and Ricketts, who now represents Nebraska in the U.S. Senate.
Some Republicans expressed outrage over the mailers, while Ricketts and others supported the campaign attacks. But the party’s actions in the legislative race marked a new level in intraparty strife. Within days of sending the mailers, the state GOP and a political consulting firm it had hired were found liable for making illegal robocalls to help Slama in the race.
The Nebraska Public Service Commission found that the automated calls were made without proper disclosure and that neither the GOP nor the consulting firm had registered with the commission or filed a script of the call with the commission, as required by law.
Kamron Hasan, an Omaha attorney representing the Nebraska GOP, said the party is disappointed by Friday’s ruling.
“We’re still looking at next steps at this point,” he said.
veryGood! (565)
Related
- 'Kraven the Hunter' spoilers! Let's dig into that twisty ending, supervillain reveal
- Catch up on our Maryland bridge collapse coverage
- Massachusetts man gets 40 years in prison for fatal attack on partner on a beach in Maine
- Mississippi Senate Republicans push Medicaid expansion ‘lite’ proposal that would cover fewer people
- Paige Bueckers vs. Hannah Hidalgo highlights women's basketball games to watch
- Millions in India are celebrating Holi. Here's what the Hindu festival of colors is all about.
- Sophia Smith, Portland Thorns sign contract making her NWSL's highest-paid player
- Robotic police dog shot multiple times, credited with avoiding potential bloodshed
- Hidden Home Gems From Kohl's That Will Give Your Space a Stylish Refresh for Less
- MLB Opening Day games postponed: Phillies vs. Braves, Mets-Brewers called off due to weather
Ranking
- Meet 11-year-old skateboarder Zheng Haohao, the youngest Olympian competing in Paris
- 'Such a loss': 2 women in South Carolina Army National Guard died after head-on collision
- What to know about the cargo ship Dali, a mid-sized ocean monster that took down a Baltimore bridge
- Christina Applegate says she has 30 lesions on her brain amid MS battle
- Most popular books of the week: See what topped USA TODAY's bestselling books list
- Tour group of 33 stranded kayakers, including children, rescued from cave on Tennessee lake
- Macaulay Culkin Shares Sweet Tribute to Best Friend Brenda Song
- Ex-Trump lawyer Eastman should lose state law license for efforts to overturn election, judge says
Recommendation
Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow owns a $3 million Batmobile Tumbler
A man has been arrested for randomly assaulting a young woman on a New York City street
NFL's rush to implement new kickoff rules is Roger Goodell's latest winning power play
Beyoncé 'Cowboy Carter' tracklist hints at Dolly Parton, Willie Nelson collaborations
Paula Abdul settles lawsuit with former 'So You Think You Can Dance' co
Lea Michele Is Pregnant, Expecting Baby No. 2 With Husband Zandy Reich
Pennsylvania’s mail-in ballot dating rule is legal under civil rights law, appeals court says
Kouri Richins Murder Case: How Author Allegedly Tried to Poison Husband With Valentine's Day Sandwich